Example Review: Reviewer View

This reviewer view presents the running example as a decision packet for a human reviewer. It suppresses operational detail that the reviewer does not need while preserving the approval meaning that the design and runtime views must still respect.

Reviewer Objects

• Review Intake
• Decision Packet
• Review Outcome

Reviewer Morphisms

• summarize-for-review: Review Intake -> Decision Packet
• compare-policy-and-scope: Decision Packet -> Decision Packet
• approve-or-return: Decision Packet -> Review Outcome

Reviewer Invariants

• The reviewer can see the requested scope, policy status, and required evidence before deciding.
• The reviewer view preserves the distinction between policy evaluation and human judgment.
• A positive Review Outcome must correspond to the canonical Approved Change state.

Relationship To Other Views

This reviewer view projects design/commutative-diagram.md into a human decision perspective. It aligns with runtime/runtime-view.md by preserving the same approval meaning under different labels and omitted detail.